Why Good Candidates Disappear During a Slow Recruitment Process
(blank)
25-Sep-26
Why Good Candidates Disappear During a Slow Recruitment Process
We completely understand why companies want to take their time when recruiting.
Hiring someone is an important decision. You want to meet candidates properly, make sure they have the right experience, introduce them to the right people and ultimately feel confident that you're making the right appointment.
But there is a balance.
One of the things we've seen repeatedly over the years is companies losing excellent candidates, not because there was anything wrong with the job, the salary or the business, but simply because the recruitment process took too long.
The problem is that while a company is making its decision, the candidate is making one too.
Candidates need to feel wanted
Think about how a candidate feels immediately after a really positive first interview.
They've met the company, they like the people, the role sounds exciting and they can genuinely imagine themselves working there. They leave the interview enthusiastic about what might happen next.
And then… nothing.
A few days pass. Then a week. Perhaps their recruiter tells them the company is still interviewing. Another week passes while diaries are coordinated or somebody internally needs to give their opinion.
That initial excitement gradually starts to disappear.
The candidate begins to wonder: Do they actually want me?
By the time the company eventually comes back wanting to arrange a second interview, the person who was incredibly enthusiastic two weeks earlier may feel very differently about the opportunity.
They haven't necessarily found a better job. Sometimes they've simply switched off.
Interviews take time for candidates too
It's also worth remembering that attending interviews isn't always straightforward when you're already employed.
Companies understandably want to conduct interviews during the working day, but that can leave candidates having to rearrange meetings, invent reasons to leave the office or use annual leave simply to attend.
One interview is usually manageable. Two or three interviews, particularly when they're spread over several weeks, become considerably more difficult.
Later in the year this can be even more of an issue, when candidates may have already used most of their annual leave.
So every additional stage and every unnecessary delay creates another opportunity for a good candidate to decide that the process simply isn't worth the disruption.
Your recruitment process says something about your company
There's another element that employers sometimes overlook.
The recruitment process is one of a candidate's first experiences of your organisation.
If arranging interviews takes weeks, feedback is slow and nobody seems quite sure what happens next, what impression does that give?
Fairly or unfairly, a candidate may start wondering whether that's how the company operates generally.
Is decision-making always this slow? Is there lots of bureaucracy? Will getting anything approved be difficult?
Conversely, a well-organised recruitment process can create a very positive impression. Quick communication, clear expectations and prompt decisions suggest an organisation that knows what it's doing.
The best recruitment processes aren't necessarily the shortest
We're certainly not suggesting that companies should rush important hiring decisions.
Some positions genuinely require several interviews. There may be technical assessments, presentations or meetings with senior people. That's perfectly reasonable.
What matters is that the candidate understands the process from the outset.
If there are going to be three stages, tell them.
If the Managing Director needs to meet the final two candidates, tell them.
If you know there will be a two-week gap between stages because somebody is away, tell them.
Candidates are generally very understanding when they know what's happening. What causes frustration is uncertainty.
Keep the momentum going
The companies we recruit particularly successfully for tend to have one thing in common: their recruitment process is slick.
They know roughly what the interview process will look like before it begins. Candidates understand the stages involved. Feedback follows interviews quickly and, when somebody progresses, the next stage is arranged promptly.
There is momentum.
That doesn't mean making rushed decisions. It means removing unnecessary delays from the process.
Because if you've interviewed somebody you really like, there's a good chance somebody else will like them too.
And the longer you leave a good candidate wondering what happens next, the greater the chance that the excitement they felt when they walked out of that first interview will have disappeared by the time you decide you want to see them again.
Take the time you need to make the right hire — but don't mistake a slow recruitment process for a thorough one.
Previous Articles
Latest Articles
Blog
- 25/09/2026
- Why Good Candidates Disappear During a Slow Recruitment Process
Why Good Candidates Disappear During a Slow Recruitment ProcessWe completely understand why companies want to take their time when recruiting.Hiring someone is an important decision. You want to meet candidates properly, make sure they have the right experience, introduce them to the right people and ultimately feel confident that you're making the right appointment.But there is a balance.One of the things we've seen repeatedly over the years is companies losing excellent candidates, not because there was anything wrong with the job, the salary or the business, but simply because the recruitment process took too long.The problem is that while a company is making its decision, the candidate is making one too.Candidates need to feel wantedThink about how a candidate feels immediately after a really positive first interview.They've met the company, they like the people, the role sounds exciting and they can genuinely imagine themselves working there. They leave the interview enthusiastic about what might happen next.And then… nothing.A few days pass. Then a week. Perhaps their recruiter tells them the company is still interviewing. Another week passes while diaries are coordinated or somebody internally needs to give their opinion.That initial excitement gradually starts to disappear.The candidate begins to wonder: Do they actually want me?By the time the company eventually comes back wanting to arrange a second interview, the person who was incredibly enthusiastic two weeks earlier may feel very differently about the opportunity.They haven't necessarily found a better job. Sometimes they've simply switched off.Interviews take time for candidates tooIt's also worth remembering that attending interviews isn't always straightforward when you're already employed.Companies understandably want to conduct interviews during the working day, but that can leave candidates having to rearrange meetings, invent reasons to leave the office or use annual leave simply to attend.One ...- 21/04/2026
- iCAN launch Diversity & Inclusion initiative in Leeds
The Team at Aston Charles were delighted to be delighted by their friends from iCAN (the Insurance Cultural Awareness Network) to the launch of their new Chapter in Leeds. This is iCAN’'s 7th region, and the event was timed to coincide with International Women’s Month. The event was held at Markel’s office in Leeds City Centre. After half an hour’s informal networking, we were treated to a keynote from Harpeet Kaur, former winner of The Apprentice, and then moved on to a fascinating panel discussion full of practical insights and inspiring discussions on inclusion, mentoring and allyship in the work place. The panel comprised Echaunti Swan (Moderator) - Diversity & Inclusion Manager, iCAN, Joanne Sykes - Divisional Director (Broker), Markel UK, Nick Houghton - CEO, JM Glendinning and Tia Howard (Cert CII) - Senior Account Manager, McCarron Coates Ltd. This was followed by some more informal networking over drinks and canapes....- 31/03/2026
- Valentine's Day Quiz
The Team at Aston Charles put their new found artificial intelligence skills to good use by organising a Valentine’s Day music quiz, featuring AI images depicting famous loves songs set in and around famous financial services landmarks such as Lloyd’s of London, The Bank of England, Wall Street, the Gherkin and Leadenhall Market. The competition attracted dozens of entries from across the insurance world, and was eventually won by Melanie Jordan (and family!) of Attis Insurance Brokers. Congratulations!...- 31/03/2026
- Aston Charles Sponsors Leeds Insurance Institute Annual Dinner
The Team were delighted to once again sponsor the Insurance Institute of Leeds Annual Dinner. The glitzy black tie event was held at the Royal Armouries, and raised over £4,500 for the Institute’s chosen sponsor, the Leeds South & East Food Bank. Co sponsors include Liberty Specialty Markets, Weightmans and Markel UK, and the Aston Charles Team were joined by guests from such esteemed companies as Marsh, Kentaro, Howden, Hudson Foster and United Legal Assistance. ...- 11/11/2025
- Increased Fire Safety Reinsurance Facility Provides Relief to More Customers
Increased Fire Safety Reinsurance Facility Provides Relief to More Customers Over the last couple of decades, lots of new high-rise structures were built with types of flammable cladding and render such as aluminium and polyurethane. In recent years, many leaseholders have discovered that they are living in buildings which do not meet fire safety standards. The Grenfell fire tragedy highlighted the risk associated with these buildings, and very quickly it was realized that there was a problem on a huge scale.This has caused alarm, worry and distress for leaseholders, which has then been compounded by the practical problems of remediating the fire safety issues and insuring the building.In 2019, mortgage companies began to request EWS1 forms before providing a mortgage. These “External Wall System 1” forms are provided by qualified professionals to indicate the fire safety of a building’s external wall system – particularly for buildings over 18 metres in height. The EWS1 forms then filtered down to insurers. Underwriters had to react to the reality of the risks that were declared on the forms, with the truth often being that a fire could cause loss of an entire building. This had a significant effect on insurance policies, with many insurers unable to accept the risk at all. Insurance brokers began to find policies very difficult to arrange, and where they were available, the prices had increased beyond reasonable affordability. In some cases they had risen by 1000%.[i]An impossible positionLeaseholders were then left in the unenviable position of needing to remedy the safety of their flats while paying astronomical amounts for buildings insurance, as well as living with the emotional drain of knowing that their home was unsafe. Unable to sell, unable to reduce costs, and with bills to remediate the cladding issue that were unfeasibly high, homeowners were in an impossible situation.Property and casualty insurers knew that they needed to respond to the problem, but ...- 24/07/2025
- What does the rise of “nuclear” verdicts mean for commercial insurance?
The US has seen a rise in recent decades of so called “nuclear” court verdicts – referring to huge payouts; higher than could be anticipated. They often run into multiple millions or even billions of dollars. One research paper, looking at 1288 nuclear verdicts between 2013 and 2022, put the average payout at $89 million.[i]What do nuclear verdicts look like?In nuclear verdicts, damages are in three categories; noneconomic, in which compensation is paid out for suffering which is not financial, such as for chronic physical or emotional pain; economic damages, in which a plaintiff is compensated for a financial loss or burden; and punitive damages, in which the company is obliged to pay out as a punishment, and to force a change of policies or behaviour. [ii]It affects industries such as the auto industry and the medical / pharmaceutical industry and is a big issue with regards to insurance for product and public liabilities. The concern is that these nuclear verdicts are not always proportionate to the actual damage caused, and that the payouts are unpredictable and – to a certain extent – infinite, making the system difficult to manage and almost impossible to properly insure against. The US Institute for Legal Reform is concerned that rather than being “justice”, the payouts are more like a “massive payday for plaintiffs’ lawyers.” [iii]While nuclear verdicts have generally been seen as a US problem, the issue is moving into Europe. Zurich has warned that litigation funding firms are looking to enter the UK legal system and trying to purchase stakes in UK legal firms. [iv]Why do nuclear verdicts occur?One of the big reasons that nuclear verdicts can happen, is the ability for plaintiff’s lawyers to instigate fear and anger in the jurors. In recent decades this has become easier, as we have seen a healthy rise in the expectation for large corporations to take responsibility for their actions. Huge payouts may make a jury feel that the ...- 24/07/2025
- Ensuring the Future of Insurance: Educating Generation Z
A recent study has found that 25% of insurance professionals are looking to retire within the next decade, while at the same time, only 4% of young people have a career in insurance as a consideration. [i] These concerning statistics point to the risk of an imminent skill shortage within the insurance industry. As a specialist recruitment agency, we at Aston Charles are already starting to notice a reduction in the number of young people looking for jobs within insurance. While we continue to see a wide talent pool among millennials and Generation X, there are fewer and fewer young people entering at graduate level.What do Generation Z think about insurance?The figures indicating a lack of interest in insurance careers among young people is not a surprise; in fact Generation Z (currently aged between around 13 and 28) are increasingly disinterested in the concept of insurance in general. Generation Z are the least insured generation, with 17% of Gen Z adults having no type of insurance for anything (almost double the number of millennials without insurance, at 9%). [ii]Far from only being concerned about attracting Gen Z into insurance careers, we need to start from the beginning and support them to understand the importance of taking out insurance polices that can protect them in the case of unforeseen events. Once they understand this, it can be a building block upon which to open up a dialogue about the career pathways within the industry. How do we encourage Gen Z talent into P&C Insurance?For young people in their early-to-mid 20's there are already a number of exciting graduate roles available. These are a great opportunity for young people to enter the industry with lots of potential for career progression. However, we are now seeing that there is a real need for the insurance sector to start to start thinking even earlier than graduate schemes.It would make sense for insurance careers to be marketed to the younger age of the generation; even ...- 24/07/2025
- “A New Era” at the BIBA Conference 2025
In May 2025, the team at Aston Charles were delighted to be able to enjoy one of the highlights of the insurance industry calendar, with a two-day visit to the British Insurance Broker’s Association conference. Located in Manchester, this annual conference is one of the most prestigious gatherings for insurance professionals held in Europe. Aston Charles Director, James Heald says of the 2025 conference: “It was great for us to network with potential new clients, as well as having a chance to spend more time with some of our existing connections. The conference felt even busier this year, and it was such a good opportunity to see so many insurance professionals in one place.”A New EraWith the theme this year being titled, “a New Era”, the focus was on the future of broking in a changing world. The conference was centred around a realistic examination of the evolving landscape of insurance; looking at proactive responses to political, digital, economic and climate changes that are affecting the sector in profound ways.Inevitably, there was a strong spotlight on AI this year. Right from the opening speech, made by BIBA CEO, Graham Trudgill, AI was acknowledged as having a “revolutionary” impact on the industry. AI was discussed in multiple talks and panels, as well as being centre stage in a number of exiting exhibitions. The CFC interactive exhibition was especially popular, giving delegates the opportunity to explore deep fake imaging for themselves, in an AI photo booth.A focus on inclusionHappily, there was a strong focus on inclusivity at the 2025 conference. Unfortunately, we still see disparity within the industry with pay gaps and opportunity gaps for some demographics. The “women in insurance” breakfast was a great opportunity to further discuss career progression and inclusion.It was good to see a day dedicated to “young brokers” which was well attended – this was a real encouragement, given the challenges currently faced with getting more young people to ...- 14/07/2025
- Aston Charles Features In The Industry Press
Following a LinkedIn post that went (according to himself!) “viral”, Richard Jones was featured in the Insurance Post publication twice in as many weeks. Richard’s post, using an artificial intelligence generated image of the Lloyd’s of London building frozen in an ice cube, led to his contribution on a series of articles centred around ‘Are pay freezes jeopardising broker staff retention?’ Not that he checks on a daily basis, but Richard assures us that the post has made over 9,400 ‘impressions’ from people across the world, but unfortunately Richard reports that his invitation to participate on Celebrity Big Brother is yet to land at Aston Charles Towers! ...- 10/07/2025
- BIBA 2025
- The Team made their annual pilgrimage over to Manchester for the BIBA Conference. This year’s theme was ‘A New Era’, and the conference explored topics like digital transformation, artificial intelligence, regulatory changes, and emerging market trends, all reflecting the evolving landscape of the insurance industry and the opportunities and challenges they present for brokers. With over 9,500 attendees, 220 stalls and 50 guest speakers (ranging from Heavyweight boxer Anthony Joshua through to former Secretary of State for Defence, Penny Morduant!) it was certainly a varied and interesting year, and as ever, a great opportunity to catch up with friends from across the industry!...